• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Erggo

Karen@KarenCommins.com

Karen Commins

Award Winning

Atlanta Audiobook Share-rator™

  • Home
  • Demos
  • Titles
  • Reviews
  • Videos
  • Blog
  • About Me
  • Contact
  • Shop

Revoked Findaway’s License to Apple for Machine Learning

2 February 2023

As I wrote in 2021, taking steps to remove the human voice and replace it with a synthesized one destroys the art form.

I certainly do not want or intend to participate in any attempt to create artificial voices meant to replace human narrators.

However, I unknowingly may have done that very thing by choosing to distribute audiobooks through FindawayVoices.com. Today, I took action to revoke Findaway’s license to Apple to use my audiobooks for machine learning.


In recent days, people on Facebook have shared this clause in Schedule D of the rights holder’s Distribution Agreement from FindawayVoices.com:

Machine Learning
Rights Holder grants Apple a limited, non-exclusive, non-transferable, non-sublicensable right and license to use Digital Audio Products files for machine learning training and models, provided that in no event shall any Rights Holder Digital Audio Products or portion thereof be provided to any third party or end-user in contravention of this Digital Distribution Agreement (e.g. making Rights Holder content available for free to end-users without express written consent). Rights Holder may revoke this right and license by sending Notice to Findaway as outlined in Section 11.

Section 11 states:

11. NOTICES
All notices required under this Agreement shall be sent by email to support@findawayvoices.com.

I’m a rights holder on Findaway. I sent the email below to FindawayVoices as my Notice. Feel free to use it as a template, though in retrospect, I’d change the subject to be Revoke license for Apple machine learning. I also should have added that my revocation applies to any future similar license with another company. Not surprisingly, the auto-reply message stated they are “experiencing higher than average email volume.”

Subject: Revoke use of Apple machine learning

Hello. I am disgusted to learn that Findaway at some point added language to Schedule D of the Distribution Agreement which allows Apple to use my audio for machine learning.

Per Item 11 of the Agreement, I revoke that right and license forever for all of my audiobooks.

Please send confirmation of this request, as well as confirmation from Apple that my files will not be used in this manner.

Looking at my copies of past Distribution Agreements, I see that this clause has been in place since at least March 2020.

It’s unfortunate that Findaway’s lawyers banked on the fact that most people would not see or understand this treacherous clause in the Agreement.

For a company that proudly proclaims “We Love Narrators” on the home page of FindawayVoices.com, this clause makes it seem that the company loves big money more.

In addition to the royalty break-down listed in the Agreement, Findaway should be transparent about the amount of money that Apple is paying for the right to use your clients’ audio to create synthetic voices that could take the jobs of the narrators Findaway “loves”.

Thank you for your attention and immediate action.

 

Update 1:

After receiving numerous questions and comments from other narrators, I’ve edited this post to clarify that the “Machine Learning” language only appears in the rights holder’s Distribution Agreement.

I’ve narrated and self-produced a number of books that I distributed through Findaway as the rights holder. I couldn’t find a link to the current Distribution Agreement on the web. It’s contained in my Rights Holder Dashboard.

Narrators sign away our interest in the recording at the point we contracted with a rights holder. You should ensure that your contract specifically states that your voice may not be used without your permission for machine learning or any other purpose not explicitly stated in the contract.

You can send the email to Findaway. However, I imagine they would tell you to contact the rights holder(s) of books you’ve narrated to revoke their sub-license to Apple.

I would argue that the RH doesn’t have the right to sub-license MY VOICE to Apple or anyone for machine learning or anything else. Unfortunately, this particular horse at Findaway has been out of the barn for a while.


Update 2: 

The Findaway Voices Distribution Agreement doesn’t reference other Findaway/Spotify divisions. In fact, Spotify is only mentioned one time — in the table showing the royalty rates from each site.

FindawayVoices updates this Agreement when they add or drop distribution channels/partners, so I hadn’t been looking closely at each change. I don’t remember seeing emails from Findaway that itemized each difference. I seem to recall being forced to re-sign the Distribution Agreement before I could see my FV Dashboard.

Schedule D “Digital Audio Product Program Policies” talks about the types of programs they accept and starts with these 2 paragraphs:

Rights Holder acknowledges and agrees to adhere to Digital Audio Product Program Policies. Findaway may change the Digital Audio Product Program Policies at its discretion from time to time with notice to the Rights Holder.

Our content policies play an important role in ensuring a positive experience for both our users and publishing partners. Please join us in this effort by respecting these guidelines. We may make exceptions to these policies based on artistic, educational, historical, documentary, or scientific considerations, or where there are other substantial benefits to the public.

The paragraph about the sub-license to Apple for Machine Learning was strangely added at the end of Schedule D, right after paragraphs about prohibitions on Hate Speech and permissible and non-permissible Sexually Explicit content.

Actually, from a lawyer’s perspective, that’s probably a perfect hiding spot.

 

 

SHARE VIA:
Send email Mail
Share on Facebook Share
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on LinkedIn Share
Share on Pinterest Share
Share on Digg Share
Print Print

Related posts:

  1. Karen Commins’s Audiobook Marketing Cheat Sheet
  2. Commit to Creativity Workshop
  3. Feather, Phone, and Fun
  4. How to Download Clubhouse Replays

Filed Under: Authors, Narrators Tagged With: Apple, FindawayVoices.com, machine learning

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Alex Picard says

    2 February 2023 at 1:56 pm

    Karen, do you know narrators can make this request? Or only rights holders?

    Reply
    • Karen Commins says

      2 February 2023 at 2:09 pm

      Hi, Alex. Thanks for the good question.

      Narrators unfortunately don’t have any say in the matter. The language is only in the Distribution Agreement for rights holders.

      The Production Agreement that narrators sign states under Item 7 Ownership:

      Rights holder will retain all right, title, and interest in and to the Work and Audiobook including the copyright in the Work and the sound recording copyright, unless otherwise agreed upon by both parties in writing.

      If you’ve done books for a RH who distributed through Findaway, you’d want to ask them the rescind that license to Apple.

      Karen

      Reply
      • Suzanne Barbetta says

        2 February 2023 at 3:00 pm

        Karen – I just looked over my agreement as a narrator on a Marketplace Union PFH contract for them last spring and it doesn’t allude to this at all. I will reach out to my authors but I am wondering since there are still many authors on Twitter if it should not also be post there instead of only on LinkedIn? I am gong to try to track down my Australian author since she did direct distribution… Thank you for the letter above.

        Reply
        • Karen Commins says

          2 February 2023 at 6:05 pm

          Hi, Suzanne. I updated the post to indicate that the language is only in the rights holder’s Distribution Agreement. The rights holder is the only one who can revoke the sub-license right.

          When I publish an article, it automatically posts to Twitter and LinkedIn. The software is supposed to also share the article on my FB business page. That usually doesn’t happen, so I manually add it there.

          My blog articles also are sent to my email list the next day to either narrators or authors, depending on the subject. This one will go out to both groups.

          I hope this info helps.

          Karen

          Reply
  2. Cath Bilson says

    2 February 2023 at 8:26 pm

    This is genuinely outrageous because I don’t believe that Rights Holders actually HAVE the right to assign narrators’ voices to be used for Machine Learning (unless they are also the narrator). Any chance of SAG-AFTRA getting involved?

    Reply
    • Karen Commins says

      5 February 2023 at 4:24 pm

      Hi, Cath. While I agree with you, you’ll have to refer the question about SAG/AFTRA to the union reps.

      Karen

      Reply
  3. Ella Lynch says

    3 February 2023 at 6:00 am

    Thank you so much for sharing this Karen. I am absolutelt appalled and disgusted. Despite not being a rights holder, I have used your email template any way, in the hopes it has some effect. And I am now going to reach out to all my authors about it too.

    Reply
  4. Thomas Nance says

    3 February 2023 at 9:47 pm

    Thank you, Karen. I used your template to revoke the permissions for Apple to use my fiels for AI voice construction.

    Reply
  5. Ian Russell says

    5 February 2023 at 10:09 am

    Thank you for bringing this to the communities attention. It feels like a backdoor. Automatically passing a license relating to our voice data to Apple via the Rights Holders agreement

    Reply
  6. Maggie Foster says

    10 February 2023 at 11:06 pm

    It seems to me that the person holding the rights to the audio file should get the money being paid my Apple to use that file for machine learning.

    Reply
    • Karen Commins says

      13 February 2023 at 12:25 pm

      Hi, Maggie. Thanks for your perspective.

      The person holding the rights to the audio does not have the legal right to use the performers’ voices for anything other than the distribution of the audiobook unless the performer specifically agreed to it in the contract.

      As a result of the publicity over the clause in the Findaway Distribution Agreement, reps from SAG/AFTRA met with Findaway and Apple. Both companies agreed to halt the use of any and all files for machine learning, retroactive to the beginning of the practice.

      To my knowledge, compensation for any files previously used was not discussed. However, if any amount is ever paid, it should flow to the person who owns the voice, not the recording.

      Karen

      Reply
  7. Stina Nielsen says

    11 February 2023 at 11:59 am

    Bravo! Thank you for your statement & for publicizing this!👏👏👏👏👏

    Reply
  8. Veleka says

    23 March 2023 at 4:44 am

    Thank you, Karen! ♥ ♥ ♥

    Reply

Have a comment or question? Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Blog and Newsletter Subscriptions

Categories


Blog Archives

Most Popular Posts

  • How To Become an Audiobook Narrator
  • Audiobook Narrator Self-Assessment Quiz
  • Public Domain Narration Headquarters
  • Finding Your Own Road to Tara
  • ACX U - Acting With Intention
  • 4 Keys to Becoming a Successful ACX Audiobook Producer
  • Links to Help Narrators Research Rights Holders to Books
  • Karen’s Primer on Narrating Royalty Share Audiobooks
  • How to Use My Twitter Lists

Links Section

  • NarratorsRoadmap.com
  • AudiobookMarketingTips.com
  • My Tuesday Tips on Twitter
  • Press Page
  • AudioForAuthors.com

More of My Articles

ACX Blog:
  • A Narrator’s Look At Audiobook Marketing Part 1
  • A Narrator’s Look At Audiobook Marketing Part 2
  • How to Act Like An Audiobook Narrator
LinkedIn:
  • Setting Boundaries in Your Voiceover Business
VoiceOverXtra:
  • For a Good First Impression With Audiobook Producers,
    Share Your Audible 'Customer Rating'
Blog and Newsletter Subscriptions

Categories


Blog Archives

Links Section

  • My Tuesday Tips on Twitter
  • AudioForAuthors.com
  • AudiobookMarketingTips.com
  • Links to Help Authors Know Their Rights
  • YourAudiobookProducer.com
  • How to Use My Twitter Lists

Other Articles

DigitalBookWorld.com:
  • 4 Ways Planning For Your Audiobook Can Make You a Better Writer
  • Make Audiobook Production Your Goal in 2016
  • How Amazon and Audible are Pushing Audiobooks Into the Mainstream
  • Authors, Can You Afford to Produce an Audiobook?
InD’tale Magazine:
  • Audiobooks: A Multi-tasker’s Best Friend!
  • A Week In The Life of an Audiobook of an Audiobook Narrator
ACX Blog:
  • A Narrator’s Look At Audiobook Marketing Part 1
  • A Narrator’s Look At Audiobook Marketing Part 2

Erggo

Karen@KarenCommins.com

© 1999-2023 Karen Commins // Site design by Voice Actor Websites // Affiliate links to Amazon are used on this site.